Mountain Mortgage logo

Fixed Rate vs Adjustable Rate Mortgage in Alabama and Florida (2026)

If you are choosing between a fixed rate and an adjustable rate mortgage, one question decides it: how long will you keep the loan? An adjustable rate mortgage (ARM) starts with a lower payment for a set number of years. After that, the payment can rise. The right choice depends on your timeline and on how much of a payment jump your budget can absorb.

Start Your ApplicationGet a Quote

Fixed rate vs adjustable rate at a glance

Feature 30 year fixed 5/6 ARM
Rate Stays the same for 30 years Fixed for 5 years, then can adjust every 6 months
Starting payment Usually higher Usually lower for the first 5 years
Payment after year 5 Principal and interest stay the same Can rise or fall, up to the caps in your loan
Best fit You plan to stay a long time or you need a payment that never changes You expect to sell or refinance before the fixed period ends

What top ranking pages cover and what they miss

Search results for this topic come from national sites such as Fortune, Bankrate, ConsumerAffairs and Rocket Mortgage. They explain the definitions, list the pros and cons, and show current ARM rates. They stop short of the question a buyer actually has. How many dollars does the ARM save me, and how fast does a rate jump take those dollars back? This page runs that math on one loan so you can see the break-even point yourself.

1. What the numbers in 5/6 ARM mean

The first number is the fixed period in years. The second number is how often the rate can change after that, counted in months. A 5/6 ARM holds one rate for 5 years, then the rate can change every 6 months. Older 5/1 ARMs changed once a year.

The consequence is that the lower starting payment has an expiration date. Know the date before you sign.

2. The savings in real dollars

Here is an example with made up rates on a $400,000 loan. Illustrative example. Not a rate quote or offer of credit.

Loan Example rate Principal and interest
30 year fixed 6.50 percent $2,528.27 a month
5/6 ARM, first 5 years 5.75 percent $2,334.29 a month
Difference 0.75 point lower $193.98 less a month

Over 60 months the ARM saves $11,639 in this example. That is the prize. Now look at the price of that prize.

3. What rate caps do to your payment

After 5 years the ARM balance in this example is about $371,049 with 300 months left. Suppose the loan has caps of 2/1/5. The rate can rise 2 points at the first adjustment, 1 point at each later adjustment, and 5 points over the life of the loan. Here is the payment at each rate, calculated as if that rate held for the remaining 300 months.

Rate after year 5 Principal and interest Change from the starting ARM payment
5.75 percent (no change) $2,334.29 $0
7.75 percent (first adjustment at the 2 point cap) $2,802.64 $468.35 more
8.75 percent $3,050.55 $716.26 more
10.75 percent (life of loan cap) $3,569.83 $1,235.54 more

Real ARMs recalculate the payment at each adjustment, so your numbers will differ. The shape does not change. A cap protects you from an unlimited rise, but a capped rise can still be large. Use the free mortgage payment calculator to test your own price and down payment.

4. The break-even question: how long will you keep the loan?

In this example the ARM saves $193.98 a month for 5 years. If the rate lands at 7.75 percent and stays there, the ARM payment is $2,802.64 and the fixed payment is $2,528.27. The ARM now costs $274.37 more each month than the fixed loan.

Divide $11,639 by $274.37 and you get about 42 months. So the savings are used up around month 102, roughly 8.5 years into the loan. This ignores the small difference in principal paid. If you sell before that point, the ARM came out ahead. If you keep the loan past it, the fixed rate was cheaper.

5. Why a planned exit can fail

Many buyers choose an ARM because they plan to refinance or sell before the rate adjusts. Both exits can fail for ordinary reasons. A refinance needs enough income, credit and home value at that time, and it costs closing costs. A sale depends on the market and on your own life changing on a schedule that nobody controls.

Ask one question before you pick the ARM: can my budget carry the capped payment in the table above? If the answer is yes, the ARM risk is one you can afford. If the answer is no, the lower starting payment is a loan against your future budget.

6. Alabama and Florida details that stack on top of the rate

Under any loan type, property taxes and homeowners insurance are paid through escrow and can change each year. In Florida, homeowners insurance is a large piece of the monthly cost in many areas. In Alabama, your county and wind and hail deductible can change the picture. These costs change your total payment whether your rate is fixed or adjustable, so an ARM adjustment lands on top of them. See how cost stacking can reduce the cash you need at closing, and read our guide to whether mortgage points are worth it before you decide how to buy down a rate.

Which loan fits your plan

Your situation What to weigh
You expect to sell within 5 years An ARM can fit, because you may sell before the first adjustment.
You plan to stay 10 years or more A fixed rate usually fits, because the payment never resets.
Your budget has no room for a payment jump of $468 to $1,236 a month Choose the fixed rate and keep the payment predictable.
You have a clear plan and savings for a payment increase An ARM may work. Test the capped payment first.

Start with the loan type that fits your credit and down payment. Our conventional loans page covers the standard options, and our monthly payment estimator shows payments by loan amount. If you are comparing lenders, read how to compare mortgage lenders in Alabama and Florida.

Start Your ApplicationGet a Quote

Frequently asked questions

What does 5/6 ARM mean?

The first number is how many years the rate stays fixed. The second number is how often the rate can change after that. A 5/6 ARM keeps the same rate for 5 years and then can adjust every 6 months. Older 5/1 ARMs adjusted once a year. Read the terms on your own loan to confirm the schedule.

Is an adjustable rate mortgage cheaper than a fixed rate mortgage?

An ARM usually starts with a lower rate than a 30 year fixed loan, but not always, and the gap changes from week to week. The lower rate lasts only for the fixed period. Ask for both options on the same day and compare the Loan Estimates side by side.

What are ARM rate caps?

Caps limit how far the rate can rise. They are usually written as three numbers such as 2/1/5. The first is the most the rate can rise at the first adjustment, the second is the most it can rise at each later adjustment, and the third is the most it can rise over the life of the loan. Your loan documents list the caps that apply to you.

Can I refinance before my ARM adjusts?

Maybe. A refinance depends on your credit, your home value, your income and the rates available at that time, and it carries closing costs. None of those are guaranteed five years from now, so treat a refinance as a possible exit and not as the plan.

Does a fixed rate mean my whole payment stays the same?

No. A fixed rate keeps the principal and interest payment the same for the life of the loan. Property taxes and homeowners insurance still change, and those are paid through escrow. Your total monthly payment can still move on a fixed rate loan.

How do I see a fixed rate and an adjustable rate side by side?

Request a quote and ask to compare a fixed option and an adjustable option where an ARM is available for your loan. Then use the payment calculator to test the higher payment before you decide.

Start Your ApplicationGet a Quote

Examples are illustrations and not rate quotes or offers of credit. Rates, caps and loan availability vary by borrower, property and program. Payments shown are principal and interest only and exclude taxes, insurance and mortgage insurance. Mountain Mortgage NMLS #2720886 | Paul Leara NMLS #2233772. Equal Housing Lender.

Back to blog